Deadline to submit Hall of Fame nominations: August 31
| 1989 | Waldo Henderson, Curtis Moore, Joseph Hanley, Donald Walter Joseph |
| 1990 | Percy Senechal, Charlie Nichols |
| 1991 | George Littlejohn, Gordon Coffey, Bill James, Percy Watts, Clement Aloysius “Oakie” O’Connor, Rheal Cormier, Joseph Walter O’Toole, John Harvey |
| 1992 | Scott Harvey Sr., Paul Joseph Hodgson, Thomas George Thompson, Lawrence Melvin Scott Harvey Jr. |
| 1993 | William Leo Donovan, Victor Lewis, Eugene “Foggy” Boudreau, Jimmy Fox, Bill McBeath, Bill Saunders, Rene LeBlanc, Charles Hassel Murphy |
| 1994 | Art Leggatt, Farther George Parent, Leo Paul Aube, Burns Vickers |
| 1995 | Walter Vautour, Billy Daley, Pat Chambers, Earl Williams, Richard “Cuffy” McLaughlin, Francis Joseph Dunn, Kenny Cripps |
| 1996 | Robert Fulton, David Kiley, Joe Breen, Angus “Sonny” MacDonald, Arthur Edward “Bush” Nickerson |
| 1997 | Doctor Guy L. Sorel, Darragh “Plush” Moore Peterson, Wayne “Hike” MacPherson, Vincent Churchill McIntyre |
| 1998 | Phillip A.J. Bourgeois, the 1951-1954 Junior Keefe Cubs, Blaine Stewart Sillikers, Ted McQuinn, Paul Luc “Tubby” Melanson, James Michael Maxwell Sr. |
| 1999 | The 1956 Chatham Head Tigers, John-Guy Robichaud, Bill O’Donnell, the 1975 Chatham Senior Ironmen, Terry F. Whalen Sr. |
| 2000 | Victor Ray Fitzgerald, Harold Rodney Wilson, |
| 2001 | Christopher Wayne Macpherson, Harry Osborne Stephenson |
| 2002 | Keith Coughlan |
| 2003 | Phillip Doiron, Clarence Joseph Girouard |
| 2004 | Agnes McCarthy, Dale Allen |
| 2005 | Joseph Cook, Brian King, Francis J. McHugh, Ron Hardy |
| 2006 | Arthur Murray Jeffrey, Stephen A. Hachey, Thomas F. Cusack, the 1971-1990 Lancaster Expos, Richard Leggatt |
| 2007 | David McManus, Gerald Roy |
| 2008 | Matt Stairs, the 1974 Fredericton Condors, Mike Keating, Ed Dunham, Brent Hallett |
| 2009 | Craig “Hopey” Hope, Thomas O’Reilly, Billy Harris |
| 2010 | Winston Edward White, Richard Neil Thorne, the 1952, 1953, 1956, and 1959 Woodstock Senior Lions |
| 2011 | Clarence “Quip” Moore, Rodney Arthur Wilson |
| 2012 | David Watling, Robert Landry, the 1957-1969 St. Stephen - St. Croix Team |
| 2013 | Thomas Benjamin King |
| 2014 | Jon Joseph Lindsay |
| 2015 | Bud Mawhinney, the 2001-2002 Saint John Alpines |
| 2016 | The 1991-1993 Newcastle Cardinals, Jason Dickson, John Phillip Cann |
| 2017 | The 2006 Moncton Mets |
| 2018 | Gerry Leblanc, the 1978-1982 St. Stephen Sabres, George Allen Lewis, Derek Wilson |
| 2019 | The 1982-1983 Saint John Dodgers, James (Jim) Anthony Born, Colin Dale Ring |
| 2022 | The 1968-1971 Junior Keefe Cubs, Matt Jenkins |
| 2023 | The 1985-1989 Moncton Mets, Michael Dunnett |
| 2024 | The 1942 North Shore Regiment Team, Mike Skidd |
| 2025 | The 1980-81 Marysville Royals Team, Terre Hunter |
